Dont know if anyone found this yet...but I was playing through Heavy Rain today, and I got to the part where you run from the police, I slipped a few buttons, and got caught. I decided to quit the game before it saved so I could get away from them, and while the scene was reloading, I got the trophy for getting caught, then was able to replay and get the trophy for getting away. I thought it was kinda cool...just thought I'd share.
