Gaming news is needed whether you get it from them or not. Journalism is a craft. Writing isn't everyone's strong suit much less making it concise and accessible to lower leveled readers. Professional criticism also has value but is very susceptible to corruption by bribes (not to mention it degrades awfully if there's some prejudice or laziness).
I'm not a fan of IA but this section of this video is something I think we can all agree is something that must be stopped [video=youtube_share;Km3DZQp0StE]http://youtu.be/Km3DZQp0StE?t=22m1s[/video] EDIT: somethings wrong, just start watching at 22min in