I don't mean to double post because the last post was a while ago, but I just wanted to let everyone know that I received the four Amiibos I ordered from Gamestop.com and they all arrived in perfect condition. They were nicely padded with airpaks and in an oversized box! So I would say it's safe to order Amiibos online from Gamestop.
Didn't wanna chance it, so I just replaced them. I think it's a stupid practice considering at my local Gamestop they keep them locked up and the prices are posted on the racks.